Oh my gosh, what a week we had. It seemed to go by so fast. A couple of days ago, I let the dog out, but had to run to N’s gymnastics class. I left the dog outside since she wasn’t finished and assumed someone would let her in. Although the dog isn’t my responsibility, I’ve been the only one taking care of her, but you’d think someone would think to let the dog in at some point, right? Apparently not. When I got home an hour later, I went to greet the dog, but she wasn’t where she normally likes to hang out. I went outside to call her in, but she isn’t there. Finally, everyone starts asking where she is and it is obvious no one knows where the heck the dog went. We all assumed she must’ve gotten out somehow. I did suspect something else must have happened because there were no signs of her digging under the fence, and I’ve seen this dog jump before, there was no way she could’ve jumped over the fence. Still, I went door to door asking everyone if they’ve seen the dog around. Seriously, I had about half the neighborhood helping us look. (I love my neighbors!)
In the end, it turns out that Max’s owner stopped by since she was supposed to be dropped off back home that day. The owner knocked on the door (I guess no one heard him knocking), and the heard the dog barking out back so he went to check it out. Well, Max was so happy to see his owner, that he decided to just take the dog home early and left his business card stuck on the door. (It fell off by the time I got home and no one noticed it in our panic). What a nightmare that was.
Anyway.
Coffee. Ice Cream. Oreos.
When I was a child, I loved coffee ice cream. I actually loved the way it tasted, and it made me feel so grown-up and sophisticated. I think that ended up shaping my tastes in coffee later in life because up until recently, I could only drink coffee that reminded me of ice cream, lots of sugar a cream. It only makes sense that I make a coffee-based ice cream, amped up a bit with a nice helping of crushed Oreo for contrast.
Since I’ve been so obsessed with ice cream, I ended up buying a few new ice cream books, and was immediately smitten with the ice cream book from Ample Hills. Although I adored the method of ice cream making from Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream, Ample Hill’s use of skim milk powder was really intriguing. I decided I had to try out one of their ice creams. I ended up using their strongest coffee ice cream base and paired it with Oreos to help cut down some of the strength from the coffee and lend a bit more sweetness. What I love about this coffee Oreo ice cream is how intense the coffee flavor is, and the skim milk powder helped to lessen the amount of milk and eggs needed in the custard.
All in all, this coffee Oreo ice cream is a real winner in my house and everyone is completely addicted. Their favorite part of the ice cream? Digging around for large chunks of Oreo.
Don't have an ice cream maker? No problem! Learn how to make ice cream without an ice cream maker here.
Recipe Card
Coffee Oreo Ice Cream
Ingredients
- 2 ¼ cups whole milk
- 1 heaping cup coarsely ground dark roast coffee*
- ¾ cup sugar
- ½ cup skim milk powder
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 2 egg yolks
- 18 coarsely crushed Oreos
Instructions
- Heat the whole milk on medium-low in a large saucepan until it becomes hot, but is not yet simmering. Add the coffee grounds and turn the heat to low and allow the coffee to steep in the milk for about 5 minutes, stirring occasionally. Turn off the heat, and allow the coffee to steep for an additional 10 minutes.
- Strain the mixture through a cheesecloth, getting as much of the milk from the coffee as possible.
- Return the milk to the saucepan and turn the heat to medium. Stir in the sugar and the skim milk powder and mix until the milk powder is completely dissolved. Stir in the cream. Stir the mixture frequently for about 10 minutes (being sure to scrape the bottom of the pan to prevent burning), or until the mixture just beings to bubble around the edges and turn off the heat.
- In a small bowl, beat the yolks, then slowly add two cups of the milk mixture to the yolks while constantly whisking the yolks. Once the mixture is completely incorporated, Pour the yolk mixture slowly into the saucepan while constantly whisking the saucepan. Put the heat back on medium. Constantly whisk the mixture until it becomes thickened. It should become visibility noticeable that the mixture has thickened, but to be sure, you can run your finger down the back of a wooden spoon that's been coated with the mixture. If the line remains, then the mixture is thick enough.
- Remove from heat and put the custard in an ice bath for about 20 minutes, then transfer to a large ziplock bag and chill in the refrigerator until it reaches 40 degrees F (about 3 hours, but preferably overnight). Note: to cut down on time, you can carefully transfer the custard directly into the ziplock bag and put the bag in the ice bath.
- Churn the custard in an ice cream maker according to manufacturer instructions. Begin to pour your ice cream into your air tight container, stopping to add layers of crushed Oreos every so often. I like a lot of Oreo in my coffee ice cream, so you may reduce the amount of Oreo you use.
- Freeze for about 3 - 4 hours, or until the ice cream is solidified and scoopable.
Danielle B says
Just had my first bite! SO GOOD.
I started yesterday afternoon, let the mix sit overnight in the fridge, churned this morning with the oreos and finally had some tonight! I had a bit of trouble separating the grounds from the milk (thinking I could use my french press... NOPE.) Followed the recipe pretty much verbatim. I also used Sweet Bloom Coffee Roasters Costa Rica blend that I had ground at a local coffee shop. Best idea I had all week! Thank you for sharing!!
Scoops like a charm.
Joanne Bruno says
Oh my gosh, I can totally imagine how panicked you were about the dog! Glad it all turned out to be okay, but SHEESH. I would have stress eaten like three containers of this flavor!
GEORGE HERNANDEZ says
Hey, JoAnne, what a coincidence! What to do if you don't have an ice cream maker?
Amanda Powell says
I have a post that touches on this exact thing! https://cookienameddesire.com/how-to-make-ice-cream-without-an-ice-cream-maker/ I hope its helpful! If you have any other questions, please reach out!
Christine says
Hey, long time no chat! Yum coffee oreo ice-cream...I can't wait to have an ice-cream maker again. I only had one for one summer before coming to China and now that our tickets are booked back to the US I can think about buying things for the kitchen again soon! FYI, I love how you're finding new ways to photograph each of your ice-cream creations!
Amanda says
I know, it's been forever! I am on a serious ice cream kick right now. You should see my freezer right now! This was the first ice cream to go, my mom and sister devoured it in maybe three days. You will be back in the U.S. Soon, right? That must be exciting!! (Ps, thanks! It's really stretching my creativity to make each ice cream photo shoot different enough from one another!)
Julianne @ Beyond Frosting says
I love the combination of coffee and Oreo!
Danae @ Recipe Runner says
Coffee and Oreos in ice cream, doesn't get any better than that!
Christina @ Bake with Christina says
Two of my favorites! Coffee & Oreos?? Pass me a bowl full!!! 🙂
Jocelyn @BruCrew Life says
We love coffee inspired desserts! This ice cream would be the perfect summer treat!
June Burns says
Mmm what a delicious ice cream flavor! Looks very refreshing 🙂
Beeta @ Mon Petit Four says
Oreo ice cream is my favorite! I'm so excited to try this! And how frightening with the missing dog - that'll sure give you a panic attack. I'm glad all was well and OK in the end though! 🙂 XO
Medha @ Whisk & Shout says
Beyond obsessed with the flavor combo, but moreso with the pictures and that ADORABLE ice cream container! Pinning!
Amanda says
Isn't that ice cream container the best? When I saw it at HomeGoods I bought a bunch of them!
Kathryn @ FoodieGirlChicago says
Sounds like a great summer treat!
Judy@ImBoredLetsGo says
Sounds like a delicious combination! Is there a recipe???
Amanda says
Yes, it is up now! I am not sure why it wasn't showing up before. Sorry for the inconvenience!!